How We Review Garden Robots

Every score on this site uses the same criteria, so you can compare robots fairly and see why we rank them as we do.

Our sources

We are upfront about this: our rankings are research-based. Unless a review says otherwise, we have not run each product in our own yard or pool. Instead we combine:

  • Maker documentation: spec sheets, manuals, warranty terms and app features.
  • Independent hands-on reviews from established publications and testers.
  • Owner reports: forums, long-term owner reviews and recurring complaints, which we weight heavily for reliability.
  • Price history to judge value and when models tend to be discounted.

When we do test a product hands-on, the review will say so clearly.

Robot mower criteria

CriterionWeightWhat we assess
Navigation & mowing25%Accuracy, coverage pattern, shade performance, edges
Terrain20%Slopes, grip, rough ground, lawn size
Ease of setup & app20%Install effort, mapping, zones, scheduling
Reliability & support20%Owner-reported faults, warranty, parts, service
Value15%Price vs capability, typical discounts, running costs

Pool robot criteria

CriterionWeightWhat we assess
Cleaning coverage30%Floor, walls, waterline, steps, surface
Filtration20%Leaves vs fine debris, capacity, ease of cleaning
Reliability20%Getting stuck, cable or battery issues, warranty
Usability15%Weight, retrieval, app, scheduling
Value15%Price vs capability

Prices

We quote makers' launch or list prices (last checked November 2026). We never display Amazon prices, because they change constantly. Always check the current price before buying.

Independence

We earn commissions from some links (see our affiliate disclosure). Commissions never affect scores or rankings.

Corrections

Found an error? Email [email protected]. We review every report and update the page's date.